How to Repair Scratches & Dents in Your Butcher Block

A butcher block countertop or desktop brings natural warmth and character to any space. Its solid wood construction makes it functional, durable, and beautiful for any home kitchen, personal office, laundry area, or public restaurant, bar, school, or venue setting.

However, with everyday use comes the occasional scratch, dent, or surface mark. In fact, one of the drawbacks to butcher block countertops are their tendency to develop stains and scratches during use.

The good news? Most blemishes on a butcher block can be repaired easily at home with just a few tools and a little know-how.

So, for example, if you’ve accidentally dropped a pan, slid something heavy across the surface, or simply noticed wear over time, knowing how to restore your butcher block will help keep it looking like new for years to come.

Let’s walk through the best methods for fixing scratches and dents, as well as some simple maintenance tips to preserve your investment.

Steps for When You Have Scratches/Dents in Your Butcher Block

1. Make Note of the Damage

To start, you should clean the butcher block surface with a mild dish soap and warm water to remove any debris or oils. Once the area is dry, examine the damage.

Light surface scratches may only require sanding and refinishing, while deeper dents might benefit from a moisture-based repair technique before sanding.

2. Repairing Light Scratches

For small or shallow scratches:

Lightly sand the area using fine-grit sandpaper (220-grit is ideal).
Next, sand with the grain to avoid additional marks.
Wipe away sanding dust with a clean, damp cloth.
Apply a coat of food-safe mineral oil or butcher block conditioner to restore the wood’s natural luster and protection.

3. Lifting Out Dents

Wood fibers can sometimes be rehydrated to remove dents. Follow these steps:

Dampen a clean cloth or paper towel and place it over the dent.
Apply a warm household iron to the cloth for a few seconds at a time, using medium heat and light pressure.
The heat and moisture cause the wood fibers to swell, lifting the dent back to level.
Once the area dries, sand lightly and reapply oil or finish as needed.

4. Deep Scratch Repair

In the case of more significant damage, try to:

Lightly sand the surrounding area to smooth out rough edges.
Fill the scratch with a matching wood filler or sawdust mixed with wood glue.
Once dry, sand flush with the surface and clean away dust.
Refinish with mineral oil or your preferred butcher block finish to blend the repair.

5. Prevent Future Damage

Always use cutting boards for food prep.
Keep the surface dry—avoid standing water or spills that can raise the grain.
Reapply mineral oil every 3–4 weeks (or as needed) to keep the wood conditioned and resistant to marks.

If you have further questions on how to protect your butcher block investment, please contact our team today by giving us a call at 608-566-6903.

Why Choose Forever Joint Tops?

Since 2012, and with 50+ years of combined lumber experience, Forever Joint Tops, has served customers with Red Oak, Hard Maple, Hickory, and Walnut wood solutions. Our team takes pride in crafting quality butcher block countertops, kitchen islands, desktops, bar tops, floating shelves, and cutting boards made from 100% American-grown hardwoods.

So, why should you choose butcher block for your home? Every piece is built with precision, care, and attention to detail to ensure unmatched durability and timeless beauty for your kitchen, dining room, or home office. Explore our full collection of butcher block products to find the perfect fit for your home or business.

If you need further assistance with butcher block installation, maintenance/cleaning, finishing/staining, and more, please contact our team today.

Get a Quote Today!