Pros & Cons of Butcher Block vs Granite

Comparing Butcher Block to Granite Countertops

Are you looking to update your kitchen or dining room space?

Choosing the perfect countertop material can transform your home’s look, feel, and functionality. Two of the most popular options—butcher block and granite—each bring their own charm, durability, and maintenance requirements.

Whether you’re creating a cozy farmhouse kitchen or a clean, modern dining room space, understanding the pros and cons of both materials will help you make an informed choice.

If you have immediate questions for our team, please don’t hesitate to contact us! Contact us here, or call us at (608) 566-6903 for an estimate on your butcher block installation.

Get a Quote (608)-566-6903

Kitchen Butcher Block Countertop Installation

Butcher Block Countertops & Islands

Butcher block countertops and islands offer a warm, organic aesthetic that complements nearly any design style—from classic, to contemporary, to rustic. Made from carefully joined strips of wood, these natural wood surfaces create a natural and inviting centerpiece for any kitchen.

Pros of Butcher Block:

From light Maple or Oak, to deep-colored Walnut, butcher block countertop surfaces are the perfect choice for a timeless look! Let’s take a look at why homeowners may choose a butcher block installation over granite:

Warm, Natural Wood Surface: A butcher block countertop top brings a timeless warmth and beauty to your kitchen, that, depending on your preference, is unmatched when compared with synthetic or stone materials.
Easy to Refinish: Even with daily wear-and-tear, any scratches, stains, and wear can often be sanded and resealed, giving your countertop a like-new look for years to come.
Versatile Customization: Available in a variety of wood types such as Maple, Oak, Hickory, and Walnut, a butcher block countertop can be customized by tone, edge profile, and finish.
More Dish-Friendly: Unlike stone, a butcher block wood surface is more forgiving if you accidentally drop glassware or dishes.
Eco-Friendly Choice: When responsibly sourced, a kitchen or dining room butcher block countertop is a renewable, sustainable material.

Cons of Butcher Block:

Even with all of its benefits, butcher block wood surfaces do have a few drawbacks as well. Before you order butcher block for your kitchen, it’s worth researching and understanding the following:

Regular Maintenance is Required: To preserve its beauty and durability, butcher block must be sealed or oiled periodically (unless it is a finished countertop, find out more about that here on our finishing and care page).
Butcher Block is Susceptible to Moisture Damage: If you’re not careful, without proper sealing, prolonged water exposure can cause warping or staining.
Wood Surfaces Tend to Show Scratches: While easy to refinish, the soft nature of wood means scratches or dents may occur more readily than with stone.

We discuss more about the pros and cons of butcher block countertops in our article linked here. If you have any questions or concerns, our team is here to help! Please give us a call directly at (608) 566-6903.

Granite Countertops & Islands

Ok, now let’s talk about granite and its pros and cons.

Granite countertops are a luxurious, durable choice for your kitchen. Mined from a natural, polished stone, granite offers an attractive look for upscale or modern kitchens.

Granite is a favorite of many homeowners thanks to its attractive appearance and modern, sophisticated style. But is it the right choice for your kitchen? Let’s review all the pros and cons of a granite countertop surface:

Pros of Granite:

Granite provides homeowners many benefits, so if you have the budget for it, it’s well worth the investment! Let’s take a look at the benefits that a granite countertop offers:

Extremely Durable: One of the best benefits of granite is that it’s highly resistant to heat, scratches, and normal kitchen wear and tear.
Low Maintenance: Once properly sealed, granite resists stains and bacteria, making cleaning a quick and easy process. If low to no maintenance is a priority, you may want to consider granite.
Luxurious Aesthetic: Available in a wide array of colors and patterns, a granite countertop and island helps to add a sophisticated look to any kitchen.
Long Lifespan: If you’re looking for “lifetime countertops,” with the proper care, granite countertops can last decades without needing replacement.

Cons of Granite:

So why not choose granite? There are a handful of reasons why you may want to opt for butcher block countertops instead. These reasons include:

Higher Cost: Granite can be significantly more expensive than butcher block wood, this is especially true for custom cuts or rare patterns.
Difficult to Repair: While granite is highly durable, in the instance that it does need a repair, be prepared to open your wallet. Cracks or chips in granite are difficult and costly to fix.
Requires Professional Installation: Due to its weight and complexity, a granite countertop surface will need to be installed by experienced professionals, whereas butcher block countertops can be DIY-ed if you feel comfortable enough to install the countertops yourself.
Cold and Hard Surface: While elegant, granite lacks the warmth and comfort of natural wood, which may be a deal-breaker for some homeowners.

Butcher Block & Granite Installation FAQs

Below are some of the most frequently asked questions related to butcher block vs granite countertop installations. If you have further questions, please don’t hesitate to contact the Forever Joint Tops team at (608) 566-6903:

Which countertop material is easier to install?

Butcher block is generally easier to install, especially for DIY enthusiasts. Granite, due to its weight and fragility, should always be installed by professionals.

How often should butcher block be sealed?

For best results, apply a food-safe oil or sealant every 3–6 months depending on usage and exposure to moisture. We discuss more about mineral oil and beeswax application in our article here.

Can I place hot pots directly on either surface?

You can safely place hot pans on granite, but butcher block should always be protected with trivets or pads to prevent scorching and damaging the wood.

What’s the average lifespan of each material?

Properly maintained butcher block can last 20+ years, while granite can last a lifetime if well taken care of.

Why Choose Forever Joint Tops?

At Forever Joint Tops, our butcher block experts specialize in crafting quality butcher block countertops and islands from 100% American-grown woods. Our woods include Hard Maple, Red Oak, Hickory, and Walnut. Each piece is carefully built to enhance both residential and commercial spaces with lasting beauty and performance. Whether you’re remodeling your kitchen or designing a new one from the ground up, you can trust our team to provide unmatched craftsmanship and customer service. Browse our full selection of butcher block products to find the perfect fit for your home project.

Have questions about butcher block countertop installation or need expert guidance? Please refer to our guide to butcher block installation here, or contact our team today at
608-566-6903 and let Forever Joint Tops help you create a kitchen that’s as functional as it is beautiful.

Butcher Block vs Granite: Which Works Best for Your Kitchen?